2316 S St

Eureka, CA

Extraordinary Redwood Estate with Income Potential & Possible Lot Split!

An exceptional opportunity to own a distinctive redwood estate with the added potential for rental income, multigenerational living and future investment possibilities! Tucked among towering redwoods on 3 separate parcels totaling approximately 1.61 acres, this remarkable Eureka property combines architectural distinction, privacy and versatility. The separate 2-bedroom guest quarters offer exciting possibilities for supplemental rental income, while the property's three parcels present potential opportunities for a future lot split, separate sale or development. Whether you're seeking a private luxury residence, a property with income potential or a unique long-term investment opportunity, this exceptional offering deserves a closer look.

Originally designed by renowned architect Angus McSweeney, the approximately 2,953 sq. ft. main residence is filled with distinctive architectural details and extensive custom wood, stone and tile work throughout.

The dramatic living room captures the character of the home with vaulted open-beam redwood ceilings, a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace and a wall of windows framing the surrounding redwood forest. Natural light fills the space, while direct access to the backyard and expansive deck creates a seamless connection between the home and its private setting.

At the heart of the home is a beautifully appointed custom kitchen designed with both style and function in mind. Quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, a large island with breakfast bar, custom glass tile backsplash and hammered stainless steel farm sink are complemented by an impressive ILVE stainless steel 6-burner range with double oven, rotisserie and pot filler. A separate KitchenAid wall oven, built-in microwave, refrigerator and dishwasher complete the appliance package. The adjoining dining area is surrounded by windows, while custom lighting, architectural beams and luxury vinyl plank flooring continue through the main living spaces.

The home's flexible floor plan provides an array of possibilities for bedrooms, offices and private suites. A solarium opens directly to the deck and redwood forest, while the primary bedroom enjoys corner windows overlooking the trees, crown molding, architectural beams, custom lighting and a walk-in closet with built-ins. The primary bath features dual sinks, a slipper tub surrounded by stone, custom tile shower with multifunction shower panel and a lighted, self-defrosting mirror. Additional bedrooms and baths carry the home's custom detailing throughout, including stone accents, tile work, smart toilets and thoughtfully designed storage.

Upstairs, an additional bedroom features redwood-paneled walls, built-in storage and access to substantial unfinished attic storage. An oversized finished double garage provides even more storage and includes its own full bathroom.

Separate Guest Quarters – Exceptional Income & Living Potential
One of the property's most valuable features is the separate 2-bedroom guest quarters, creating an exciting opportunity for potential rental income or independent living arrangements. With its own private entrance and fenced area, this additional living space offers flexibility for extended family, guests, multigenerational households or potential rental use.

The guest quarters feature a wraparound partially covered deck, vaulted open-beam ceilings and a wall of windows overlooking the redwoods. The inviting living area showcases parquet flooring and a brick fireplace with built-in cooktop, while the kitchenette includes wood cabinetry.

Two bedrooms provide comfortable private living space, including one with a brick fireplace and woodstove and another with wood-paneled walls, built-in cabinetry and direct exterior access. The guest bath is a standout, featuring a handmade vanity with customized fantasy coastal resin doors and tempered-glass vessel sink, a vintage-inspired iron and porcelain bathtub, custom tile surround, smart toilet and laundry facilities.

The opportunity to enjoy the main residence while potentially generating supplemental income from the separate guest quarters adds another dimension to this already exceptional property.

Three Parcels – Additional Investment Possibilities
Beyond the potential income from the guest quarters, the property's 3 separate parcels totaling approximately 1.61 acres offer another compelling opportunity. The possibility of a future lot split, separate parcel sale or additional development adds an intriguing dimension to the property's long-term investment appeal.

For buyers looking beyond traditional homeownership, the combination of a distinctive primary residence, separate guest accommodations and multiple parcels creates an unusual opportunity to explore both immediate lifestyle benefits and longer-term investment possibilities.

A Private Redwood Setting
Outside, the setting is every bit as special as the home. Expansive decking overlooks the surrounding redwoods and established landscaping, creating a peaceful backdrop for outdoor living, entertaining or simply enjoying the natural beauty of the property.

Abundant driveway and off-street parking provide convenience and flexibility, while a leaf-filter gutter system and three wooden storage sheds, including one with a new corrugated clear roof, add practical functionality.

A Rare Opportunity for Luxury Living & Investment Potential
With its architectural pedigree, extensive custom craftsmanship, private redwood setting, separate guest quarters and three parcels, 2316 S Street offers much more than an extraordinary place to call home. It presents the possibility of enjoying a distinctive luxury residence while exploring supplemental rental income, multigenerational living and future parcel opportunities.

Live beautifully among the redwoods, enjoy the flexibility of a second living space and explore the investment possibilities of this truly one-of-a-kind Eureka property!

Buyer to independently verify rental eligibility, required permits and feasibility of any proposed lot split, separate parcel sale or development with the City of Eureka and other applicable agencies.