1456 C St
Eureka, CA
Victorian Grandeur, Rare Scale, and Exceptional Value
This storybook Victorian is a rare blend of historic charm, meaningful updates, and opportunity—set on a sunny corner lot with a south-facing yard and multiple structures that create a truly special offering.
At approximately 3,200 sq ft, the main residence features 5 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, two generous common living areas, a formal dining room, and an abundance of original or period design details throughout. From the intricate trim work to the many beautiful vintage and period light fixtures, the character here is intact and undeniable. Updated kitchen and bathrooms provide a strong foundation, while the home’s scale and layout offer flexibility that’s increasingly hard to find.
Out back, a private courtyard connects all three buildings, creating a peaceful, tucked-away outdoor space complete with an enchanting water fountain—a rare and charming feature that adds to the sense of retreat. The property also includes a detached oversized two-car garage and a separate studio unit with a full kitchen and bathroom, ideal for extended guests, rental income, creative use, or work-from-home needs.
The upside is substantial: historic homes of this size, with this level of character, multiple structures, and outdoor space, are seldom available at this price point. For buyers with vision, this is an opportunity to steward a classic Victorian forward while building long-term value.